Journalist praises Florida's ban on Open Carry

[Miami_JBT]

https://outline.com/dmMdv9

Even in gun-lovin' Florida — where you can fish with an AR-15 — we have our limits

I frequently write about what Florida does wrong. But today I’m writing about what Florida has done right. And remarkably, it’s on the topic of guns.

Don’t get me wrong: Florida is gun-crazy in many ways.

We hand out concealed-weapons permits like Tic Tacs, leading the nation. And we’ve pioneered the homicide-inducing stand your ground gun law — which was written by a lawmaker who is also a funeral home owner. (Conflict of interest?)

But we’re not all-the-way crazy.

Florida has refused to join the rush of other states to sanction the open carrying of firearms.

“Open carry” laws are why you see scowling young men cosplaying as military commandos in political protests in other states, standing often with AR-15s slung over their chests among crowds of protesters.

When former President Ronald Reagan was governor of California, he signed the Mulford Act, a law that specifically outlawed open carry, after members of the Black Panther Party began patrolling the streets of Oakland while brandishing loaded weapons.

The Heller case, a 2008 landmark U.S. Supreme Court gun-rights decision, stopped short of a blanket, unfettered Second Amendment right to open-carry firearms.

"Like most rights, the Second Amendment right is not unlimited,” Justice Antonin Scalia wrote in the majority opinion. “It is not a right to keep and carry any weapon whatsoever in any manner whatsoever and for whatever purpose.”

Florida, despite its reputation as the Gunshine State, has remained one of only four states that prohibits open carry by law. And state lawmakers have resisted efforts by gun-rights groups to change that.

A bill to allow open carry in Florida passed the Florida House in 2016 but died in a Senate committee. And a year later, the Florida Supreme Court upheld the state law banning open carry in a case brought by a St. Lucie County gun owner.

In Florida, open carrying of weapons is sanctioned when you’re fishing, hunting or camping.

So every once in a while, open-carry advocates make a display of this exception by standing on a congested Intracoastal bridge, pretending to be fishing with their AR-15s hanging from their shoulders.

Florida’s ban on open carry looks wise now, considering how the open display of firearms has become a form of visual intimidation used at political protests during this hotly contested election.

The gathering of Arizona protesters supporting President Donald Trump outside the elections office in Phoenix included men legally displaying their military-style assault weapons.

And the interrupted plot to kidnap and kill Michigan’s Gov. Gretchen Whitmer called for a swarming of 200 armed militia members at the state Capitol — a place where open carry is permitted and the sight of civilian commandos armed to the teeth was not unusual.

After the arrests of militia members in the plot to kill the governor, Michigan tried to ban the open carry of firearms in polling places on Election Day. But the state courts ruled that the guns would have to be allowed in the polling places.

So, take heart, Floridians. We’re not that crazy.

We may have no shortage of aggrieved hotheads and Trump dead-enders riding around in their flag-flying Vanilla ISIS pickup trucks.

But the AR-15s these self-deputized “patriots” crave to display will have to be imaginary.

I don't see FL getting OC again.... it will be killed this session like it is every other session.

[dammitgriff]

It seems no one is addressing the obvious, i.e., open carry is Constitutionally sanctioned by default and government at any level has no business regulating by law the Second Amendment.
Case law built around arguments to the contrary are in prima loco unlawful.
R/Griff

[Miami_JBT]

It seems no one is addressing the obvious, i.e., open carry is Constitutionally sanctioned by default and government at any level has no business regulating by law the Second Amendment.
Case law built around arguments to the contrary are in prima loco unlawful.
R/Griff

State Supreme Court and the State Constitution says otherwise.

[dammitgriff]

It seems no one is addressing the obvious, i.e., open carry is Constitutionally sanctioned by default and government at any level has no business regulating by law the Second Amendment.
Case law built around arguments to the contrary are in prima loco unlawful.
R/Griff

State Supreme Court and the State Constitution says otherwise.

Still un-Constitutional.
We need to stop listening to the government—and especially its courts at all levels—give their opinion on what is and isn’t Constitutional, as they are clearly biased against its restrictive legal cannon.
The main purpose of the Constitution is to define our government and to restrict it; that is, to restrict it from interfering with our inherent liberties. Since most of our population is “educated” in government-run schools, we have a massive case of collective ignorance on this matter.
Open carry should be left for the individual to decide...IF we lived in a free country where the government respected the Constitution. It does not, and we are not free.
R/Griff

[flcracker]

Florida, despite its reputation as the Gunshine State, has remained one of only four states that prohibits open carry by law.

I'd like to see a summary of the open carry laws/rules in the other 46 states. I know in some states, you gave to be a resident of that state. In other states, you have to possess a CWP issued by that state - out of state CWP reciprocity does not always apply to open carry.

[Chigger]

Wouldn't expect anything different from Frank Cerabino who's afraid of his own shadow and writes about yankee carpet baggers in Boca, his own people.

[Tenzing_Norgay]

"Journalist"...

Cerabino is a choade. Hopefully he'll be neighbors with his buddy Gary Stein, soon.